Have Your Say: What Do You Think?

Thank you to everyone who took the time to voice opinions regarding Hilary Duff's shameful choice to support animal abuse. If you are visiting, please read this comment section to see just how many of Hilary's fans are appalled at her behavior.

Hi. I found your site very nice. thanks for it! good luck!

Good Work!s

Son of a bitch. What an ass hole.

I can't belive this!!!!! I saw on a board today on neopets [a website] about hilary duff and that this hated her. I didn't like her before but now I hate her EVEN MORE! I cannot belive this!! She's ugly, she's rude, she's fake, AND she supports animal abuse!!! What next, supporting abortion?!?! Come on!!

this is total bull shit its not true hilary duff loves animals she has one u dicks are retards serporting this shit

this is total bull shit its not true hilary duff loves animals she has one u dicks are retards serporting this shit

What the hell? and i THOUGHT she cared. She is such a b!tch, SHE should start to HELP the animals and HELP BAN bullfighting and steer wrestling and all that stuff then maybe people would be more on her side! then against her!

this is all simply not true!you all are jealous of hil!!!so you write disgusting stuff about her!!!

Guys, Hilary duff didnt really support animal abuse because the picture with the arrows being shot into the bulls backs,looks terrible but that is only allowed in Spain. They just put that in there to make it seem than it really is. Plus they are going to slotter the animals anyway so it doesnt really matter, plus she could be there for protestin. i love animals just as much as the next guys

I dont believe that hilary duff would do something like that liers.Your just tring to ruin her fame.Your just jealous beacause she is so beatiful and such a great actress and singer,dont even try to open your huge mouth again about my favourite star.

HILARY DUFF IS A SON OF A BITCH!I ACTUALLY CRIED WHEN I WATCHED THOSE CRUEL VIDEOS

I used to like her music... until just now. How can she live with herself, the stupid worthless oblivious cruel THUG!

I realise that its the animal abusers themselves that need to be brought to justice, but to claim to be animal minded and then work with these animal torturers is hypocritical. I also think as a public figure she has a duty to be a responsible role model to her fans and everyone else that might be impressionable on these importatn matters

hilary duff is not cruel

Don't understand how people come up with things like this. I know for a fact that she is not like this!! I have known her for the last 4 years!! I can't see how any of you can say these things about her when you don't even know her....

patrick here Hilary is not an abuser of animals, and she had no control over what happened in the bullring after she left. she is all that is good overall and u all need to look inside her to see the love she really has she is a true performer and solid actress. she would never do anything to hurt animals as i said before get over it everyoner this should not even be a part of this site. she is a dear sweet friend and person, just because she performs in bull rings when they are NOt killing animals why does that make HER the abuser? she is just doing her thing and performing how can that be grounds for animal abuse? she has no control over what her money is used for once it leaves her hands. u all are placing blame on the wrong person. you should blame the owners not our hilary. Hilary and haylie are the sweetest people I know and they try so hard. Please reconsider and look at it from her point of view? she deserves it and she is my friend

Hey guys I thinking you are taking this out of context. Hilary is my best friend and I will support her all the way!!!

Hilary is a loser. Thumbs down. Booooooooooooooo!!!!!

I liked Hilary Duff a lot but not anymore.Actually a while ago I was trying to find tickets for her performance but after I found out how cruel she is no way I'm going.I remember once on Neopets(It's a online site)People were arguing about who was better.Kelly Clarkson or Hilary Duff.At that time I was on Hilary's side but no more.She's cruel.She's rude.I think Kelly Clarkson is much better.

How can she be such a idiot? supporting animal abuse? What a B!tch.

Why did you do it?

shame on u duff SHAME ON U!!!

I would not say I was her greatest fan but I like her until this came along. Sorry Hil, can't go with it. You are a not nice.

I would like to ask Hilary is she has no shame about selling herself as a caring person who stands for something and then hides like some nervous twit when she is called out. You've been outed baby. Now we know you'll sell yourself cheap, and that you stand for nothing but a few extra bucks. When your career dies for lack of talent, maybe we'll next see you walkin the streets.

If Hilary is trying to dispoint her fans she has done a wonderful job. She is so cruel.

Any idiot can see that rodeos and bullfights are terrible animal cruelty. For anyone to pretend otherwise is lunacy. Duff's fans who try to stick up for her are beyond stupid, and Duff is too rotten for words to describe.

Hey Um. I would like to say Why are you doing this to these animals? I wouldn't have the heart to do it, i cried even seeing the pictures. I cant beleive the people are STUPID enuf to support this even Hilary. I mean imagine you being abused, being killed, not being able to see another day or your family. And you think Hilary Duff is Cruel Supporting it... And meanwhile You Guys are the ones that are Abusing them and killing them, Now to Me Thats Cruel. Thats the same thing as a murder if animals were people. But to me Animals are people even though they cant talk, they are people. I have a dog and i treat him with respect, i treat any animal with respect. To tell the truth i have more respect for animals than i do woth people.

I am really shocked. I thought Duff was so much more than this kind of trivial, do-anything-for-bucks performer. I hope you keep the pressure on. She needs to be taught a lesson. Thanks!

Woowww.. This is so horrible.. How can youhh support something like this.. Just seeing this video made me crie.Knwoing that such a popular person could do something like this!> Its so cruel no animal deserves to die like this . It's wrong. Hillary duff is a loser! . I hope somone teachers he a lesson

hilary you really fooled me but now ill never beleve you again. you are sooo mean.

I Cannot beleive that hillary would do this, it's so un-nessary, if you ask me this is animal cruelty at the most high, kill bulls and horses is like killing the future animals and soon there will be no horses or bulls left, knowing hillary she gets what she wants..... most of the time. I seriously think she should go die because for her to have fans of all ages if a little child found out well lets say that it's gonna disturb lots of people, i watched the first clip and was really mad that the so called "pop star" was doing this. I am so shocked.

Hilary duff is just new and young. she is just 19.You guys are just sick. Hilary duff perfoms at rodeo so what, she is just an entertainer. I agree that the thimgs which happen at rodeo are not good. you guys should not criticize Hilary BUT criticize the manager of rodeo and all those people who arranged her performence. IN SHORT HILARY IS NOT GUILTY

To Julia Stoll: SHARK is simply telling the truth. Hilary claims to be a "great animal-friend," but her actions speak louder than words. A "great animal-friend" would not allow a bullfighting organization to profit from her concert. A "great animal-friend" would simply choose to perform at a venue where animal abuse is not involved. Until Hilary can explain how she can perform at the Leganes bullring, yet still somehow care about the animals that are abused there, she must and will be held responsible for helping to finance those activities. If you truly care about animals, you should be asking Hilary these questions, rather than blindly defending her.

julia you got it wrong. hilary is unfair and shark is a great animal friend.

I think, what "shark" is telling is really unfair, beacause Hilary Duff is a great animal-friend!!!!!!!!!!

She should know a lot of her fans like animals. That's probably why she pretended to like them, even though she doesn't really care. This will hurt her popularity and she deserves that.

Hilary Duff -- Loser!!!!!

Maybe someday Hil will figure out that it takes more than money and a career to be a real human being. Standing for something, really standing for it instead of just paying lip service, shows strength of character. She has shown none of that.

I think it is so horrible that she is supporting the cruelty of animals. No she might not be guilty of the actual hurting, but she is guilty nonetheless by association. I hope she see's the error of her ways and quickly corrects them. p.s she is a horrible singer and terrible actress

The comments of Ferdinand and anonymous more or less typify the attitude of many Hilary Duff fans when confronted with this issue. Since Hilary didn't commit the actual abuse herself, they see no reason to hold her responsible for what others do. The point they're missing is that Hilary is helping to finance animal abuse by allowing Rodeo and bullfighting organizations to profit from her performances at their venues. Without financing, Rodeos and billfights could not occur, but because of people like Hilary who actively contribute money to these activities, they will continue. The purpose of this website is to inform people of Hilary's involvment with this horrendous industry.

Uh you idiots duff is not the one who killing animals you idiots she sang at rodeo for godsake she didn't hit an animal she didn't participate in the rodeo she sang at one that is completely different than hurting the animals. So just shut up until you can figure she didn't do anything she sings because it's her job if you had a job and you needed the money would you turn it down?...I didn't think so. In life it all boils down to needing money eventually. these fans aren't fans anymore because Shark is feeding false information into their heads making duff look like the one who is abusing the animals...Rodeos are not abuse!

hilary is doing something really stupid. forget this loser.

k hilary is a big butt lik seriously y would anyone do tht...lik even robbing a store is better then wat she is doing. lik i never used to lik her at all but when i think about it i lik totally HATE HER LIK SO TOTALLY HATE HER!!!!I THINK IM GONNA CRY.......

I was a big fan of you but not anymore. You make me sick of what you are doing to this animals. Get a clue Hilary, you used to be a good girl now you are an animal killer creep! Do all of us a favor and get out of the acting and singing business. A LOT of people don't like you anymore and I'm included!

I'm a huge fan of Hilary Duff. But, now I have to re-think that. That really makes me sick of what she is doing to these animals. She used to be this good girl I liked but, now she is turning into an animal killer. :(

Wow you animal rights activists sickin me some of you are completely ignorant first off i read that the "tiger truck" follows hilary to where she works,lives and hangsout, now i don't know but im pretty sure that falls un der the category of stalking yeah im pretty sure...second i read a post by: dhanielle walsh-murphy that states "Lets all hope that horse slutering becomes elegale soon. VERY SOON"...Ok first of all some of us like to eat meat and just because you don't doesn't mean that you can all of a sudden ruin are lives just because you don't like something...I love to hunt my family gets food that way. You vegans aren't healthy you lack necessary vitamans to keep you healthy. second: I also read a post by: Darla Tampa, Florida that states:"Good Grief! What's going on with Hilary "I'm so sweet and innocent" and "I'll never go naked" and "I love animals" Duff? What's the deal Ms. Smiley Face? You phony. Why don't you come down to Tampa so we can protest you and let everyone know about the real Hilary Duff?" Is that all you activists do is protest oh lets protest this no lets protest that...You all have a radical opinion that hunting isn't right that eating meat isn't right and that it should be illegal...so that you can have your way and a perfect vegan world will exist and that meat eaters will have to convert...Ted Nugent is one of my favorite people he loves to hunt and so do i you people think that he just kills animals and that all hunters just kill animals NO you are wrong we use dogs to help hunt and we love them deer need to be hunted becaues they would overpopulate and die of starvation or get hit by cars how would you like that...Huh... Third you guys whine and say "hilary are you american?" how could she not be just because you don't think somethings right it's all of a sudden unamerican ok fine you guys are unamerican how about that...Also in what way did hilary duff actually abuse animals can you explain that for me i could be wrong but unless she actually did something that hurt animals im pretty sure she didn't commit animal abuse...And you wonder why hilary doesn't respond...you are targeting a young girl ferociously...All i can say is that you people are basically fascists in that you have one idea and you think that idea is the only one there should be i feel sorry for you i really do...

first she has no talent. now she does this. cant say what i think cause it wouldnt get put on it starts with b, ends with h

Wow. This is unbelievable. Not the Duff part, but this website. Just because you sing at a rodeo, doesn't make you 'cruel' Yes, bad things happen at rodeos and I do NOT support them, but taking it out on someone else because they sang at one... what does that do? She isn't the one causing the abuse to animals, is she? Just because she sings at a rodeo, doesn't make her 'cruel' This stuff the website says should go out to the actual abusers, not "by standers". Think about this.. how many celebs. do you think go to rodeos? Probably a lot, so why take it out on one person? You don't see many websites like these very often. And when you do see them, it's pitiful. Because to me, it seems like the owners of this site are just out to get Duff. Note: I DO NOT SUPPORT ANIMAL ABUSE.

I thought hil was pretty cute, but she dont look so good now. does any of the other girls do this kinda thing?

If Hilary Duff cared at all for animals she would stop these performances. The fact that she is ignoring SHARK only makes her look worse...Come on Hilary! Take a stand against animal cruelty!!!

I want to personally respond to Joey's well-written post. He states that, "Just because somebody plays at an arena does not mean that they support what happens there." I think I am on safe ground in stating that Ms. Duff would not perform at an Al Queda conference, or a Ku Klux Klan lynching or a neo-Nazi rally. She wouldn't want to have people thinking that she supported those kinds of activities. Are animal lovers really off-base then when they consider Ms. Duff to be supporting rodeos by playing at rodeos? In any case, no one can deny that she is attracting new audiences made up of young and impressionable people into that venue, for even the rodeo people declared (and lauded) that fact. This is reprehensible, especially for someone who claims to care about animals. Principled people, even poor principled people, do not sell out their ethics, and Ms. Duff is not poor. Poorly raised, perhaps. But not poor. Joey continues with: "I hate the cruelty that happens at rodeos too, but you can't just look at one side." To which I respond, sure we can. In fact, as animal protectors, the animals' side is the only side we are concerned with. For that matter, what other side is there? Joey continues: "Madrid, as far as I know is not a rich place. Rodeos and bullfighting arenas are where they make the most money for their economy and their home. If the United States was dirt broke and there was no other way for the government to get money, they would do anything too. Including cruel things." With no insult intended, I would have to say that Joey knows precious little about Madrid. It is not a poor city. Furthermore, the majority of Spaniards are opposed to bullfighting. Ms. Duff did not need to play in a bullring in Madrid; there were other venues. For that matter, she did not need to play Madrid at all. In the whole scheme of things, she did not need to play in Spain. She could have done for the victims of bullfighting what Sir Paul McCartney recently did for the seals in Canada -- he refused to play in Canada again so long as the seal slaughter continues. Ms. Duff could have refused to play Spain in protest. But she didn't, because Hilary Duff not only does NOT have the principles of McCartney -- she has no principles at all as far as we can tell. Joey finishes up with: "I hate being the bearer of bad news, but Hilary's decision to play was, at the most, a little dumb, but looking past that, when you are at that level of fame, $$$ is everything." On this point I believe Joey and SHARK on in complete agreement. For Hilary Duff, $$$ is indeed everything. I believe that each and every thing she does is all about the $$$. I don't know if there is anything that Hilary, her mom and her daddy wouldn't do for the right amount of $$$. What an utterly disgusting way of life.

That's so mean! I'm really disapointed in you Hilary.

Okay, I understand the premise of this site. So anyone who is upset at Hilary for doing what she did, please do not explode after I give my piece. Just because somebody plays at an arena does not mean that they support what happens there. I hate the cruelty that happens at rodeos too, but you can't just look at one side. Madrid, as far as I know is not a rich place. Rodeos and bullfighting arenas are where they make the most money for their economy and their home. If the United States was dirt broke and there was no other way for the government to get money, they would do anything too. Including cruel things. I hate being the bearer of bad news, but Hilary's decision to play was, at the most, a little dumb, but looking past that, when you are at that level of fame, $$$ is everything. Thank You.

Deep down inside, i wasn't very fond of the idea of making the movie a cinderella story with such a young child like you. now i completely regret it. you're too young anyway for anything, and VERY immature. you dont know what you're doing. you dont know what choices to make. you're a loser. i wish i never kissed you.

how could u do this??? wat is the meaning of this???? and how could someone be soo cruel??? hilary duff , u should know we r all very disapointed inu.

Hilary duff has a head stuffed with cotton balls!!!!!!!!!!!!

HILARY DUFF, WE ALL HATE U!!! EVEN THE PPL AND "FANS" THAT USED 2 THINK UR OK NOW THIMK SO LOW OF U, UR LOWER THAN THE DIRT!!! I MEAN, TALK ABOUT FEELINGS!!! U R JUST PLAIN CRUEL!!!! PLZ MAKE EVERYONE HAPPY AND COMMIT SUICIDE. THANK YOU.

Hilary Duff is a big fat loser and the people who she hires to do these nasty things to innocent animals should NOT do them. instead they should just do them 2 her and torture her and put it on tv so everyone can enjoy. and btw, she has a terribly juvenille voice.

I agree with Barby G. Hilary Duff is developed mentally challenged and we should all have pity on her.

Hilary duff, what has gotten into u????? did something happen to her??? is she brain damaged?????

oh, those poor animals!!!! i hope that she burns in hell!!!

hilary duff, u r the most sickest, insensitive person i have ever heard of. and since u want animals dead, DROP DEAD!!! cuz ur below the level of an animal!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hil, speaking for my friends and i,u have really let all of us down who care about u. we don't like crulty and never thought u did either.

This is one strange story. How does someone who seems to have so much going for her screw up so badly?

i always hated hilary duff because she\'s famous for something that she can\'t do, but now i hate her more! i never thought that she could do this to the poor bulls and horses! i watched the videos and i cried while watching them. she\'s not just a fake and a poser, she\'s also an anorexic animal hater! to her dumbass fans who still love her, you guys need to start realizing that hilary duff is not a good role model, an animal abuser will NEVER be a role model, got that little kids?!?! expect joel to dump her! cruel people like her needs to be arrested and put in jail. ANIMAL ABUSERS SUCK!!!

It is a terrible thing that she has done. It doesn't matter that she wasn't the person beating and killing the animals. She is linked at the hip with them, and equally guilty of cruelty.

Hilary please do not do this anymore!

Hilary Duff I have a question. Are you an American? Seriously. Are you an American? Frankly, Americans I know wouldn't just hole up like you are doing. Bin Laden, yes. Americans, no. Why not just deal with what is going on? Don't crouch behind some suit who will spout anything for a price. Hilary Duff, if you are an American act like one. Otherwise, why don't you just traipse your little Texas tail over to Afghanistan and join OBL?

I think "Heater" has trouble with abstract thought. Duff is an enabler. Figure it out. Laura, I think she has brought the nastiness on herself. She won't respond. She is hiding behind her lawyer who simply talked a bunch of trash when he was cornered. She needs to take a stand and stop looking so guilty. Or is she just as guilty as she looks?

I think all of you people are nuts, I love animals in fact I'm a vegan but your taking it too far... she sung thats it get over it and do something more important with your time...

here is an idea. Yeah Maybe she should do some research on what exactly she is supporting when doing these gigs. HOWEVER, people maybe the hateful comments should be saved for the people who are actually DOING the animal cruelty.

hey hil. does yer boyfriend know hes dating a sniveling little loser? i red you cried at an awards ceremony because yer necklace was tangled. then you go an help people who beat the &*#*&( out of animals!!!! Duff -- yer a SUPER LOSER!!!!!!!!!!

Do you people no what they do to the horses after you give them away or bring them to an auction. Well some of them go to nice homes and live happaly ever after, but some don't. They get bot for dog food. Yes it is sad but some people do not care. The horses get truked in trailers that pigs go in. If the horse is noy dead before they get to the sluter house they are very very sick. The horses get killed in the cheepist way poscibal. I cant even say how. It is a teribale thing to do to such proud and wild animals. Lets all hope that horse slutering becomes elegale soon. VERY SOON.

I am the proud father of two daughters. They love HD, but I suspect that will change when I show them this site. I thought she was a benign performer, at least not one of the young harlots out there, but clearly she is the worst of the lot.

How can anyone be so cruel and heartless that they support such brutality to animals. Hillary, you are as low as any human can be. Go back under your rock and leave the animals alone.

Alicia Silverstone played a character in the movie "Clueless." She was just playing a role. In real life she is very intelligent and she cares very much about animals. Hilary Duff is the exact opposite. Her image is one of caring for animals, but she is cruel and clueless in real life. Hilary Duff - a Cruel, Clueless Creep.

I thought Hilary was hot until I looked at this site. What a loser. Leave the animals alone, Duff.

O hilary!!!!!! i am so surprised and angry. why do this? its sooooo cruel!!!!!!!

Before commenting I watched the video on the site, so I feel that I am an informed participant. Hilary Duff, there is no way I can say what I think about you in this forum because there is no way SHARK would put it on their site. This much I can say: You are a cold, heartless and uttlerly disgusting coward. You cavort with animal abusers and don't have the guts to even stand behind your actions. If I had a daughter who had all your popularity and made all your money, but had that huge yellow streak going up her back that you have, I would hang my head in shame. I predict that your public appeal will fade, and quickly. You're not a star. You're an animal abuser packaged to look like the all-American girl. When the public finds out it has been defrauded, it will reject you, you pitiful, pitiful excuse for a human being.

i think that yall people on this site really shouldnt be talking about someone this bad like this i mean if she did it then yeah thats wrong but yall shouldnt be downing her so bad but then again that makes her a really bad person i would like to say to hilary that she fooled me and many others i thought that she was a very sweet nice person , but me and many others were terribly wrong because she is wrong for that!!!! Hilary you should get yourself in check sweetie

i used to love hilary duff. i can't believe anyone could support animal abuse, and make it look like they don't. I don't like her anymore. Hilary needs to get some sense.

For someone so young, Hilary has a lot of learning to do. What a shame she's uncaring RE the concert venues she's been involved in. Has she not got eyes in her head to view the video footage to learn the gruesome / cruel / stupid violence involved in rodeos + bull "fighting" + be horrified by it?

For years I have been writing action letters for various animal rights organizations opposing rodeos, bull fighting and other abuses. After reading your rebuttal letter to Ms. Duff's lawyer, I finally feel that something is really being done to help these helpless creatures. Steve, you really are like a shark...you bite and don't let go. I'm 100% behind you and admire your tenacity, courage and compassion.

I have identical twin 7 year old daughters. They loved Hilary Duff. Then I showed them your factual and informative website, and they instantly withdrew their support for her. They even drew pictures about her support for cruelty. Steve Hindi, you have made a difference, and you are my personal hero. Please keep up the outstanding work that you do..

If Ms. Duff truly cares about animals she will apologize for her rodeo and bullring appearances and never perforn at one again. There are plenty of other venues in which Ms. Duff can perform. Hilary if you care about your fans, not to mention animals PLEASE admit your mistake and make a vow never to perform at ANY venue that promotes animal cruelty.

Wow. This was the first and only time I even heard of Hillary Duff. She is not only a hypocrite, she sucks.WOW.

Hope she chokes on her "blood money". If it is ok, maybe she would liked to be roped and slammed to the ground.

Hey Hilary - Cat got your tongue???

Alexandra -- get a clue girl! She had concerts where animals were being hurt and killed. A real animal lover wouldn't stick around for that. A real animal lover would step forward and explain herself. A real animal lover wouldn't hide like a squirmy little coward. Only phonies do that. Know who sucks up to phonies? Bimbos. Don't be a bimbo, Alexandra.

hillary duff is a crule phonie and i wont spend any more on her!!!!!

Hilary is so nice to animals and there is no possible way that she can do that to poor little animals.It is true that she did have a concert there but she had nothing to do with it.LOSERS!

you guys are jerks hilary had a right to do that accept for the singing part but u guys shouldn`t kill animals for fun or for any thing u should help mother nature not kill her so please do the riht thing and stop doing all this killing how would u like it if some one was tryin to kill u,u wouldn`t like it but if u were a bull think u wouldn`t like diing ok pretend that your a bull imation that your about to die from a knife or from an arrow how would u like it so i`m on hilarys side!!!

this is shocking! i never thought rodeos were this horrible! excuse me if this sounds brutal, but i would like to see miss. duff being treated the way these poor innocent bulls are. ms. duff, on the other hand, is not innocent

Hilary duff is evil

I own a club that's goal is to prevent animal cruelty.This, this CRUELTY is horrible.It's DISGUSTING to think that harming, even KILLING animals is ENTERTAINMANT!!!!They should make this ILLEGAL!!!!Hilary Duff sjould be smart enough to realize that it is wrong to even SING at one!This DISGUSTS me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GIVE HER A BREAK?!?!?!?!!?!??!?! ILL GIVE HER A BREAK IF SHE AT LEAST LOOKS AT THE BULL W/ ALL OF THE KNIVES IN HIS BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I WOULD DIE 2GIVE U A GOOD SLAP ON THE FACE!!!!!!!!!!!! U PISS ME OFF "DUFF"!!!!!!

hilary you son of gun!!!!

U FOOL!!!!!!! I HOPE U GET BACK WTVR U GAVE THOSE ANIMALS!!!!!!

To anonymous: The problem is that we haven't had any response from Hilary whatsoever, unless you count the lies from her lawyer and the pressure someone has applied to the City of West Hollywood to silence the Tiger Truck. Hilary claims to care about animals, yet through her actions Hilary has not only condoned bullfighting but actively supported it by performing at the Leganes bullring. She and the owners of the venue profited from her concert there; not exactly the actions of someone who doesn't promote bullfighting and crulety to animals. All we are asking is for Hilary to explain why she performed at the bullring, and to promise never to do so again. Until she does, people will continue to be angry with her, and rightfully so.

There is something very wrong with anyone who would engage in this cruelty, and those who cavort with them are no better. Hilary Duff can't wiggle out of this. She should do everything she can to distance herself from these inhuman creeps.

I can't imagine how Hilary Duff could perform at rodeos and bullrings with this horrid violence. I cannot even believe it. What is the point to her continuing to do this? How can any fan remain a fan? Have any of you actually looked at the video?

I had no idea what took place at these Rodeos until I watched the video you have posted on here. The views of everyone can not be changed at one time, but they can be changed one person at a time. In my opinion, people who support this type of activity see no harm in the act because it is just "what cowboys do!" I found it very disturbing and it saddens me that these animals are regarded as nothing more than a sport. To me, no matter how big or how small, we all have a right to life. This is no kind of life for these animals. What would the public think if it were there dog or cat, whatever animal they consider as family. Would they be so forgiving?

I want to know why it's Hilary's eight-year-old fans who have to stand up for her. Why can't she speak for herself?

Yee-Ha Hil? How do you spell Stupid? I spell it: H-I-L-A-R-Y-D-U-F-F

This is tottally unfair like how could you support animal abusers i think that all people who support this should be left out of the world we don't need people like them around here especailly taking one of our best singers and turning them against there beleifs hahah this abusing stuff is so friggen stupid hil what the heck were you thinking?!!

Are all Hilary fans under the age of two? They seem to have no sense of history, or tactics in social struggles. When the Exon Valdes oil tanker went aground in Alaska and polluted so much of the environment and killed so many animals, Exon gas stations were boycotted across the country. Those stations had nothing to do with what happened in Alaska, but the way to get the company's attention about what had happened was to boycott the whole thing. The entire country of South Africa was boycotted in a struggle for human rights there. Many South Africans had nothing to do with the violating of human rights, and many of them were even part of the struggle to make change, but the whole country was boycotted. There are many, many more examples of boycotts, the very concept of which seemingly eludes Hilary's clueless fans. They need to understand that while they may not care about anything else other than themselves and Hilary Trailer Trash, other do care. This boycott is part of making positive change, so get used to it kiddies. All the blond brat has to do is promise not to do it again. That she won't do that exposes her true nature, as well as her arrogance.

Hilary Duff, you should be ashamed of yourself!

I would like to tell Hilary that is she really wants to be a star, one thing she should do is think about how people will see her years from now. People follow other people who show and support the best, as opposed to the worst, of humanity. Or are you figuring to only be a flash in the pan, so you have to grab every penny you can while its hot?

Hilary fan Nick, along with some other pro-Hilary posters, give an impression (hopefully false) that Hilary Duff attracts mainly mindless and self-serving whelps that: a) have little if any intelligence, and b) have no belief structure whatsoever. If that is the profile of the typical Duff fan, they are in luck, for she obviously has exactly the same qualities. Tell you what, Nick, let's start with the basics -- two plus two equals what? Come on Nick, give it a shot!

She gave a concert in an arena also used for bullfighting, so that shows support for bull fighting? Because she failed to denounce bullfighting before her concert? Guess what. The internet is used to support terrorism, child pornography, and all sorts of bad things. You use the internet also! You must therefore be sympathetic to child pornographers! Please stop your (deleted) nonsense.

To Patrick: David and Jimbo are trying to s'plain something to you, but you either lack eyes to read or a brain to think. You bought right into the "Olympic stadium" nonsense from Hilary's lawyer. That clown was talking about a different place in a different city. How did you miss that, since SHARK refuted it in the same place? Hmmmmmm... Crooked lawyers say things like that to confuse morons, and it looks like Duff's lawyer found one in you. Or maybe you're just Hilary trying to look less like crap. One word of advice: No one respects a butt kisser ;)

i think you guyz are totally overreacting. have you actually got hilarys personal recorded say in this??? im sure she wouldnt want to offend anyone and that she wouldnt promote bullfighting and cruelty to animals, it's her career to perform! give her a rest

the stadium she was at is also an olympic stadium in 1992 and stuff she has no control over what happens there. u all need to see the person inside her a warm caring loving person, i will always be there for her and go to bat for her. she will always be my friend. patrick

Geez im glad i dont kiss butt like hilarys die hard fans. she could crap on them and I think they would just smile and eat it.

Your "multi-use stadiums" argument holds no water at all. There are lots of other places she could play. She chooses rodeos and a bullring. Again, she doesn't have to guts to speak up about this because there is no defense for what she has done and she knows it. You can be "proud of who she is," that is certainly your right. But given what she is doing, I think this site is being overly generous to her. It acknowledges her cruelty-free cosmetic line and her past service with a horse organization. Let's face it, all that is either for money or public relations. There is no generosity there. You do not explain your claim that the site has "all lies about her." What are you talking about? If indeed you are telling the truth when you state, "i dont support animal cruelty either," then come out and tell Duff to stop supporting animal abuse. If Duff was "sincere and honest," she would at the minimum come out and confront this group about what is going on. She is eighteen years old. I assume that by now she has learned to speak up, yes? Furthermore, if her mom and dad didn't teach her to speak up, well, they ain't speaking out either. Are they total morons, and do they acknowledge that there is no defense for what their "sweet little Hil" is doing? You claim that she "is so fll of lOVE," but all I see is someone who makes claims about her love for animals and then betrays them bigtime. That's what I call a phony and a traitor. I be watching for your response. I once thought Duff was pretty cool too. I'm ticked that I was taken in, and I would like for everyone to find out what she is apparently all about.

While Hilary is not DIRECTLY abusing the animals, she is hurting them indirectly by performing at places where they are being injured and killed - rodeos and the bullring. All she has to do now, is to state that she will NO longer perform at places where animals are being hurt and killed. No performer who truly loves animals would be involved in an event where animals are being exploited.

To patrick: As an adult, Hilary does have control over which venues she chooses to perform at. The fact that bullfights are one of the main events presented in the Leganes bullring is the reason people are rightly upset with her. If Hilary was concerned with the welfare of the animals used in bullfights, she could have simply chosen another venue in the area not affiliated with bullfighting. This way she could have performed for her fans in Madrid at a place where animal abuse does not occur. The fact that Hilary chose Leganes over all other venues shows that the welfare of these animals did not play a part in her decision. By performing at Leganes, Hilary has become part of the animal abuse problem, although she could easily correct the situation by explaining why she performed at Leganes in the first, and promising never to do so again. And please - enough with "it is all lies about her." Every fact on this website has been well documented and proven.

I always new that I didn't like her. But I NEVER knew she was this big of a bitch!!! She should know better!! How could she sit there and let all the animals go throuh hell????! I am going to be sure to tell any1 i know that likes her *even the littlest bit* about her. *my lil cousin looks or should i say looked up to her but after this my cousin will hate her!

I am surprised to learn of H. Duff's rodeo/bullring ties. One would think she would know better.

hello patrick here. i consider hilary duff my freind. I have a rebuttal on this website here. I know hilary would not abuse animals, or anything. she is good hearted, kind sweet and animal lover. her music stands for love and good. she performs there yes but dont forget, alot of stadiums have multi tasks. like tiger stadium is used for detroit tigers baseball, colledge games, conserts and the like. so why not a bull ring? she was there just to perform as it was a good place for alot f people to watch her sing. that stadim was probably used for alot of stuff. she has no control over whats done there. i am very proud of who she is a good hearted person. please stop the mean stuff and i recomend this part of the site be deleted . it is all lies about her. i dont support animal cruelty either but i support hilary i know she is sincere and honest. and i am proud to have her as my friend. she is so fll of lOVE, and uses her gifts of talent for all of us. lov ya hil. love from your friend patrick

Hilary Duff is one cold person. When people find out the truth about her, her career will be over.

Hilary, please, please don't do this. I don't like to see animals hurt and I don't want to see you attacked. Please be the good person I know you are.

Good Grief! What's going on with Hilary "I'm so sweet and innocent" and "I'll never go naked" and "I love animals" Duff? What's the deal Ms. Smiley Face? You phony. Why don't you come down to Tampa so we can protest you and let everyone know about the real Hilary Duff?

Doin it for the rodeo jerks and bull killers. Isn't that special! Duff, you are a piece of work. Your man must be real proud.

Hilary Duff sings at rodeos and bullfights for one reason, because she is a spoiled bratt who cares about no one but herself. I thought she was great, but I was wrong. She is mean and uncaring and arrogant.

No fan with half a brain is going to stick with such a loser as Hilary Duff.

I didn't know what all the fuss was about til i saw the video. OMG!!!!!!!! Hilary what the #^*^%#U* are u doing? :(

I wanna know about Duff's boyfriend Joel. He is supposed to be a bigtime animal person (like Duff?) Doesn't he have anything to say?????????? Is he as phony as she is?

Here's my take on this. I googled "Hilary Duff rodeo" and came up with quite a few sites that fall into two categories. The first site category celebrates Hilary being at the rodeo. That includes Hilary Duff's own site wherein she expresses her excitement and anticipation of her upcoming repeat performance at the Houston rodeo. After the Houston rodeo she declared how much fun she had, with no mention of an animal being killed just before her performance. Apparently Hilary "the animal lover" just couldn't be bothered with such trivialities. Nice girl. The other site category decries Hilary being at the rodeo, and there are a bunch of those sites. Add that to the articles in the National Enquirer and the Globe. Hilary Duff, her publicist, her managment and her lawyer (who is quoted in the Enquirer article) are obviously aware of this controversy, and yet neither Hilary Duff nor her parents say anything. That is the behavior of a guilty person. She can't defend what she did, so she doesn't - she just keeps doing it. As for the bullring concert, the owners of this site contacted her weeks before it happened. Again, she just didn't care, didn't respond, and just went ahead anyway. "Animal Lover" Hilary Duff played at a facility that tortures and kills bulls, and anyone who knows anything about bullfights knows that they also include the deaths of many horses gored by the wounded and terrified bulls. It all adds up to a greedy, cowardly person supporting animal abuse while claiming to be an animal lover. She is playing both sides of the fence to promote a "nice girl" image to make as much money as she can. The is Un-American, Un-Godly, disgusting, sleazy and repulsive. Hilary Duff should be ashamed of herself, but then that would require some semblance of ethics, morality and dignity, and so far Ms. Duff has shown little sign of having any of that. Hilary's public claim that she would not take her clothes off in any movies she might do is just attempt to prop up her image. If her "animal lover" contradictions are any indication, Duff will perform in a Larry Flynt Hustler porn flick for the right price. As for the hopefully small percentage of mindless Hilary groupies who openly admit that they will kiss Hilary's behind no matter what, I predict that when she is relegated to obscurity (which will happen before long due to her marginal-at-best talent), those groupies will blindly and mindlessly follow someone else - anyone else - because they have no lives of their own. They exist in society to follow celebrities and kiss butt. It's a dirty job, but I guess someone has to do it.

I want to respond to Giorgio from Italy. I think I know why Hilary has not answered SHARK's letter -- because she knows what she is doing can't be defended -- at least not by anyone claiming to be an animal lover. If Hilary Duff played at a Ku Klux Klan rally or a neo-Nazi conference, we would say she was supporting those bad people. When she or any other performer plays at a rodeo or bullring, she or they are supporting animal abuse. I am not a huge Hilary fan, but if I was her behavior would end it. I believe in supporting people who are really good, not just people who act good. If Hilary wants to play in her hometown of Houston, a very large city, she has lots and lots of places to perform. She CHOSE a bullring. She CHOSE to support animal abusers. As for the Leganes bullring, that exactly what it is called, so what would she think it was for? Furthermore, SHARK had sent her the letter weeks before Leganes, so she could have at least made a public statement that she did not support the horror of bullfighting. She did not, except to support the bullring and rake in the dough. What of the fact that she owns a dog? Lot of people own dogs, including rodeo people, bullfighters, cockfighters, even dogfighters, etc. Owning a dog owner hardly makes a person an animal lover. As for her dog clothing line, any money she gives from that line is a pittance compared to what she makes. The giveaway is just more public relations on her part. Finally, she did not have a horse foundation. She was for a short time a spokesperson for a horse foundation. She isn't anymore, probably because it discovered that she was supporting animal abuse. Hilary Duff is setting a horrible example with her behavior. She manipulates fans into believing she is a good person, when she is actually not only nasty, but gutless as well. At this point, knowing what I know, she makes me sick.

So here we have the crux of the problem. Alexandra nightingale's comments is typical of Hilary's core fanbase. They see her as a perfect being who can do no wrong, who loves animals because she has a dog. When confronted with the uncormfortable idea that Hilary performed at a bullring, their mind cannot process this fact in a logical manner. Thus, they reply with "these are all lies." Even though Hilary's performance at the bullring is a documented fact, her core fanbase cannot rationalize this as an action of someone who cares about animals. Hence, they deny the reality. Hilary is a perfect being who can do no wrong. Therefore, anyone who criticizes her is lying. They are haters and are jealous. This is how they rationalize Hilary's actions, since they cannot exist in the perfect Hilary world her fans have created in their minds. It is hero worship gone very, very wrong.

well, hil think that just because she is rich and famous, she can treat people and animals like they are shit

I don't know why Hilary and her entourage didn' answer to shark's letter. I'm a huge Hilary Duff fan and I don't think she supports Animal Abuse plaiyng concerts but I would like to see what the think about your letter. She plays in Houston (or in texas in general) because it's her hometown, where she was born and she gives texas people a chance to see her shows. Isn't Hilary that deciede where to play shows, she signs agreements with local concerts organizations that tells her after where to play. She probably doesn't even know that leganes was a place for bullfights but, even if she knows it's hard, really hard to believe that her shows would be Heplful for bullfights..I mean, how? One entire site abuot her cruelty? C'mon! she give tons of money to dogs by her dog clothes line and she had a foundation for horses. Think about people that really makes action, and abuse against animals.

hilary i was your biggest fan but when you screw over the animals you screw over me. if i said what i think of you now it wouldnt get posted so i will just say you no where to go and i think you suck.

This sight is cruel these are all lies about Hilary.Hilary woul never do somthing that she loves animals haven't you seen her dog.I'm am hilary duff's 1 fan.and this is very wrong

I don't now why Hil won't speak out. She should help animals and not hurt them.

Hil I thought that you were something and someone special and i used to look up to you as my role model my hero, but I guess that you are just a liar. I used to think all this crap my friends were telling was all fake but after seeing those videos i don't want anything to have to do with you. I' NEVER EVER EVER buying stuff by Duff EVER again.

Hi i am jennifer i'm from germany it was in a german young magazine about hilary duff I went immediately to the computer and have to me the side looked at stood there I also the videos looked at myself I wanted to cry immediately it so which humans in the world gives I did not think sorry,i have write some mistakes

Can't all u Hilary lovers see? She is helping bad people, and because she is a bad person herself she isn't brave enough to say anything. She's just hiding. She's not my hero any more.

Excuse me "girls," but Julia, Maria, Stephanie and Jackie, who just commented on this site, you are obviously the same person. Whoever you are, you don't care a bit about animals, that is just as obvious. You love Hilary no matter what she does. You are a person who is nowhere, has nothing going on, and has no prospects. What a boring drone. Or maybe that was Hilary doing her best to defend herself. In that case, once again, a drone.

i am proud dominican go d.r. i am still wi hilary. i dont judge her she got her reasons. plus she is not perfect no one is just one mistake and now all the fans are against her. people or fans open yor minds look is just one mistake like ya nerve done something wrong oh please.

all my friends still her fan. if you where her fan u still we be her fan no mqatter wat ever she does. go hilary u still number 1.

only because of that ya going to stop being her fan like ya perfect never done something bad

this is stupid . any one does mistake no one is perfect. oh please. hilary is still my idol.

hil-GET A CLUE!!!!!!!!! rodeos are very crule and bullfiting kills them!!!!!! STOP HELPING SUCH CREEEEEEEEEPS!!!!!!!!

I like what Grechen says and agree -- Dump Diffy Duff!

Errick -- Hilary the Cruel doesn't have an opportunity to say something? Don't judge her? Come on look at the stuff on the site!!! She has played at a bunch of rodeos. She is quiet BECAUSE SHE IS GUILTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hilary likes mean rodeo people and bullfights. nasty sicko girl. i will tell my friends and everyone.

She must have an reason why dont judge her if you dont know her reason

HILARY I HOPE JOEL BREAKS UP WITH YOU AND BE ASHAMED!I WAS JUST STARTING TO LIKE HER MUSIC AND EVERYTHING BUT JUST RIGHT KNOW THAT I WAS SEEING THE VIDEO .I KNOW WHAT A CRUEL PERSON SHE IS.I WOULD SPEARD OUT THE WORD.IHOPE THEY MAKE A LAW ABOUT PROTECTING ANIMAL RIGHTS.AND HILARR CALLS HERSELF AN ANGEL AND ANIMAL LOVER.I REALLY HATE HER KNOW!!!

I hesitate to believe stuff I read in the Star, but it looks like you have your facts in a row. Its awful that Hil is doing this.

So this is what Hilary does with her popularity? I agree -- Dump Dippy Duff!!!!

I'm no activist, but I have seen rodeos and animals are hurt. I'm surprised that Hilary would get involved with that bunch. Sorry to hear it.

Count me out as a Hilary Duff fan! I don't hand with animal abusers.

Even though Hilary isn't a great singer and can't act I liked her because she seemed nice. Now I see she is mean. Kiss off Hilary!

It is upsetting to learn the truth about Hilary Duff. It seems like everybody is acting and everything is a lie. She has so much, and she chooses to be part of this horrible abuse. How sad.

The Star rocks! Hilary Sucks! Rodeos are for idiots!!!!!!!!

I also saw this in the Star magazine I bought today.Rodeos are just cruel. Animals are really no different than people. Animals are citizens of our planet. Sure, in they can't talk, but in the pictures from the rodeo, you can see the pain and horror in their eyes. I used to like Hilary Duff, but after seeing this, I don't anymore. Like the article said, that she may not know, she has eyes, and can't she see the animlas?! Hilary, stop this cruelity!

It will be a cold day in hell before I spend so much as another penny on Duff stuff of any kind, and I will pass the word onto my friends.

After watching the videos on this site I can only say that Hilary Duff is either a grossly ignorant, or a viciously cruel person. She is no animal lover, that's for sure. She is also obviously a person who will not take responsibility for her actions. She is nothing if not repulsive.

My friends and I looked at your site and have just 1 comment. HILARY IS A LOOOOOOOOSSSSSSERRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This is the most ridiculus thing I have ever heard of!!!! Hilary Duff say she loves animals!!! She needs to think abuot what she is doing!!!!!!!

Hilary Duff proves that you can take the jerkweed out of the trailer park, but you can't take the trailer park out of the jerkweed. Way to go cowgirl! What a Duffus!

God, I can't believe this is real. I read it in the Star and figured it was a joke or something. Hilary, r u stupid or what?

I am sorry to see that Hilary Duff won't say anything about this. She has a right to say it in the USA. I believe she has an obligation to say something to her fans. If she was anything more than a total ditz she would insist on coming forward. She may be a good performer, but she is looking mroe and more like a bad person.

Is Hilary actualy part of the cruelty, or is she just a prostitute for selling herself to them for money? Either way, I think she stinks!!!!!!!!!!!

Hilary Duff, you are a sorry excuse for a performer and an even sorrier excuse for a human being.

Shame on you Hilary!!!

Im surprised Hilary hasn't responded to this? Its hard to believe, but it must be or she would sue.

Hilary, we love U! your loyal fans want 2 stay proud of u. pleeeeeze stop helping these rodeos that just hurt the animals. I watched the videos myself and cant believe u are standing with those people who are so mean to the horses and calves. say no to them!

Count me out as a Hilary fan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Duffster is just the latest celeb to get busted while using animals to bolster her image. I hate it when they do that. Congrats on busting her, and may you lay her career low.

I am shocked Hilary would be involved in this. Never would have guessed it.

This is the kind of story that just turns my stomach. Hilary Duff the animal lover exposed as Hilary Duff the animal abuse supporter. It's sickening. I hope you successfully show the world what this little witch is all about.

Hilary, why are you doing this? Do you know where the horses go or what happens to them when they are hurt or injured? Well they either get killed or go to slaughter. Would you like if if someone broke your leg then killed you? I really don't think you would . So why are you doing it to the horses. Stop supporting the rodeos that hurt horses.

I wish Hilary had more sense of obligation to her young fans, to give them good examples of how a woman should live. I thought she was a better person than this.

I hope Hilary Duff will quickly grow up and consider what she is involved in. Beyond the issue of animal cruelty, this will cause irrepairable longterm damage to her image. I know I will never see her the same way again. Her business managers should be fired for allowing her to become embroiled in this mess.

What really ticks me off is that she doesn't even have the guts to publicly say anything. She hides behind her lawyer. Hilary is a little she-coward. What's the matter, Hil? Mommy didn't teach you to talk? Didn't get past the lessons of wiggling on camera, bad acting and singing off-key?

I would love to find out where Hilary lives in Houston, cause I want to tell her she is a moron. No matter how much money she makes, that won't make her a real person. She's not a real person if she supports this cruelty and the twerp jerks who do it.

OH MY GOD!! I knew bull fighting was bad and sad but when I saw the video I burst into tears. THIS HAS GOT TO STOP! I've sent my $donation to SHARK. Did anyone notice they have to blindfold the horse or the horse would buck that fool off and be outta there!!

I have loved and respected Hilary for her positive messages starting back with her tv show. Now she has proven that is all lies. Im not just disappointed I am furious. Ill tell as many people as I can, my friends, neighbors and everyone!

I have seen lots of movies of this stupid, bad singer and even worse actrees for not get any surprise when I read about this in SHARK mail. It is like Pink (a real celebrity, singer and animal protector)said this girls are empty, selfish and they do ANYTHING for fame and money, even dance half naked in the best style of Jessica Simpson. Do anybody of you really believe that she is a real animal protector? That make-up line is just for making easy money with the real animal defenders, and also converting 12 or 13 year old girls in futures mini-shes taking advantage of the values that they try to keep for his adult life. What mother relly want that his young pre teen daughters imitate this media-creatad coorporative product

Geez Hilary, are you bucking for stupe of the year? I guess your mom and trainers can train you to put on that ridiculous grin, but not to take a stand, eh? What a sad excuse for a person! Your parents didn't raise a child, they produced a singing mannequin!

If Hilary Duff comes to Seattle, I will get people together to explain to her fans what she is involved in. I would like to get your rodeo video to show on a mobile display where she might give a concert here.

Well well, it would seem that Hilary refuses to learn from her mistakes, and insists on making new ones. What a coincidence that the Tiger Truck has suddenly received its first fine from the City of West Hollywood, even though it's been there many times before. This wouldn't have anything to do with Ms. Duff exerting her influence by pressuring the city to silence SHARK? Oh no, of course not. Pure coincidence. Hilary must have some of the most inept public relations people working for her. First she directs her lawyer to respond with ridiculous lies, and now she's threatening to turn this whole mess into a First Amendment legal battle, which of course will only attract more publicity. Smart move, Hilary. I just hope SHARK manages to get a picture of you on a sidewalk in West Hollywood gawking at the Tiger Truck as it passes by. That would be priceless. As for Hilary taking the Compassionate Performer Pledge, don't hold your breath. She makes way too much money by performing at Rodeos, and now bullrings. Money speaks much louder than abused animals to Hilary. Of course, if enough of Hilary's fans (or to be more exact, their parents) decide they've had enough of her hypocrisy and lies and stop supporting her career, we may yet hear Ms. Duff whistling a different tune in a desparate attempt to save it. Unfortunately for her, by that time it will be much too late.

I am very concerned that Hilary Duff is supporting cruelty-to-animal events such as rodeos and bullfights. What's next?...performing at dog fights and cockfights?

Hilary, u should stop being stupid right away. Rodeos are just 2 dumb!

I think that they should end Horse slughter now! it is not a very nice thing to do to these beutiful animals at all and it should be stopped.

We are very unhappy with Hilary Duff. She should be ashamed of herself for promoting rodeos. She has lost two fans.

Your campaign against Hilary Duff has forever changed my perception of her. She was a regular on my television as my girls and even my boys watched her regularly on her Lizzie McGuire show on the Disney Channel. She seemed like a very fresh and innocent young person, which is rare in the entertainment world. I'm sorry that this is apparently just an image, and not the real person. I think Hilary Duff's popularity revolves around that image, and your campaign is destroying it. I say good for you! The world should know her for what she truly is.

My friends and I are very angry about Hilary Duff's part in the rodeo and bullfighting. We are all swearing her off for good. No more concerts, music or movies.

I am an animal lover first and a Hilary Duff fan second. That doesn't mean I am not a big Hilary fan, it's just that I love the animals even more and I am so sorry and mad to see what she has done. Hilary, if you are reading this show that you care. Don't just talk. Anyone can talk.

I knew Hilary will do something like this! I hated her the moment I saw her. My hatred was just minor, now it's major! When I looked at the video, I was so shocked. I didn't know it was that cruel. Looking at the pictures and seeing it on video is not the same. She claimed to "love animals". She's a liar! I'm sure she knows about the cruel bucking strap, calf roping, wild horse race etc. Isn't it sad for the animals? I guess when they saw Hilary, they must had thought, "She is here! She's gonna save us!" but she sang for the murderers. She is a horse lover. I think it's stupid for someone to entertain those who love abusing horses! I was touched to see her with the horses at return to freedom. I thought she was nice and started liking her until I saw "Hilary Duff is Cruel" Now, I really,really,really,really HATE HER! Who's gonna follow her footsteps, Lindsay Lohan? Just one thing to say, Hilary, you're a stupid girl and I will hate you and I will ignore you eventhough you're right in front of me!

I think Hilary Duff really cares about animals. Her managers probably keep her in the dark. Someone needs to try to talk to her and let her know what is going on.

Hilary this is not what your fans expect from. You are supposed to be a good person, and not someone who is cruel and careless. Please stop doing this or you will lose us.

Duff is an idiot for getting into this kind of trouble.

I used to watch Hilary's stupid show and listen to her stupid music. I enjoyed it then, but now that I know about her it just seems really stupid. Forget you Hilary!

Hilary - Why are you acting like trailer trash?

I am a proud Mexican, and there's no way I support cruelty like bullfighting. This is embarrassment that is kept alive by tourists, and by people like Hilary Duff who keep it alive. I did not and would not attend her concert, and she was just here.

I looked at the video on this site. I hope you can expose this brat Hilary. She deserves to go back to the hole she crawled out of.

I hope Hilary Duff will think about this and stop helping bad people. She must be a good person. I think she will stop when she finds out what is going on.

What is this girl thinking? Bullfights and rodeos? Sounds like a good way to end up playing at beer parties and weddings. Even if you forget the animals, it is stupid to play at these stupid places. Show some class, girl! Or don't you have any?

Bullfighting is one of the cruelest things I have ever seen. I have seen some of Hillary Duff's movies but until she stops supporting this violence I can never look at her the same way again. And a shout out to my friend Steve from me!

As a former fan who loves animals I would like to tell Hilary that she is a sick, disgusting, and SO YESTERDAY!!!!

I have two daughters who watched Lizzie McGuire on television. Hilary Duff appeared a very innocent person, or at least her character was. It is sad to see what she is now involved in. I predict that her future as an entertainer will be brief at this rate. There are plenty of other young female performers, probably with more talent, who don't stoop to entertaining animal abusing dolts.

When I heard someone was going after Hilary I was very angry. I think she is great, but not if she is part of this!

Thank you so much for your efforts to expose Hilary for the fraud she truly is. Her performance at a bullring is a kick in the teeth to all those who care about animals who previously thought Hilary was on their side. Little did we know. How can she perform at a bullring, financially supporting the owners by putting money into their pockets, yet still claim to care about animals? Do the animals being tortured and killed on a daily basis in bullfights not matter to her? And how does Ms. Duff respond? With lies through her lawyer. Threatening letters? Protests of her concert in Barcelona? Who does Hilary think she's kidding? She may be counting on her tween fan base to remain oblivious to these matters, but unfortunately for her it's the parents of her fans who are actually supporting her by providing their daughters with money to buy her CDs, DVDs, concert tickets and Stuff products. As more and more of these parents, not to mention their children, learn of Hilary's hypocrisy and lies, the less fans she will have left to support her. To quote Hilary's hit song, she needs to COME CLEAN and admit she was wrong, and do what she can to correct the situation. Otherwise, her career may soon come to an end. Good riddance.

I don't know if this is real. If it is I am soooooooooo mad at Hilary!!!

Pages :  [ 1 ]  

Please
Support SHARK!

SHARK is a US registered 501(c)(3) tax-deductible nonprofit charity, which means your donation is tax deductible!

SHARK
PO Box 28
Geneva, IL 60134
Tel: 630-557-0176

Send us an email: info@SHARKonline.org

View our Newsletter Archives

Educate YOUR Community!
Download our "Rodeo Reality" Handout